In December 2025, 15 single-family homes came on the market in San Mateo. The city ended the month with 18 homes in inventory and 0.4 months of supply, the tightest reading of the year. Those homes sold for 105% of list price on average, after an average of 30 days on market. Four months later, in April 2026, San Mateo had about twice the inventory, homes sold for 113% of list and they went in half the time.
For a buyer still touring homes on Thanksgiving weekend, the data points one way. The holiday months shrink the number of buyers more than they shrink the number of homes. Fewer homes to choose from comes with less competition for each one, and the San Mateo County Association of REALTORS® (SAMCAR) monthly tables show the same pattern in two winters running.
| Month | New listings | Months of supply | % of list received | Avg days on market | Median sale price | Median $/sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nov 2025 | 23 | 0.7 | 107% | 23 | $1,920,001 | $1,190 |
| Dec 2025 | 15 | 0.4 | 105% | 30 | $1,920,000 | $1,214 |
| Jan 2026 | 38 | 0.9 | 108% | 30 | $2,150,000 | $1,211 |
| Mar 2026 | 61 | 1.4 | 111% | 12 | $2,375,944 | $1,496 |
| Apr 2026 | 55 | 0.9 | 113% | 15 | $2,375,000 | $1,302 |
| May 2026 | 67 | 0.9 | 110% | 20 | $2,194,000 | $1,321 |
| Oct 2026 | 43 | 1.2 | 108% | 15 | $2,375,500 | $1,356 |
All figures are for single-family homes in the city of San Mateo, from SAMCAR's monthly reports for November 2025, December 2025, January 2026, March 2026, April 2026, May 2026 and October 2026.
Tight Supply, Soft Bidding, and Why Both Show Up in December
Months of supply measures how long the current inventory would last at the current pace of sales. A reading of 0.4 in December 2025 would normally point to a frenzy. The bidding said otherwise. San Mateo's sale-to-list ratio was 107% in November 2025 and 105% in December. It then climbed through spring, to 111% in March and 113% in April 2026.
Both things can be true because months of supply only counts sellers. It has no way of counting how many buyers are still writing bids in mid-December. The low sale-to-list ratio and the longer time on market are the clearest signs of that thinner buyer pool. Average days on market in San Mateo was 23 in November 2025 and 30 in December. In March 2026 it was 12.
The previous winter looked much the same. In November 2024, San Mateo single-family homes sold for 105% of list, and in December 2024 for 104%. Both months had 0.4 to 0.5 months of supply, and December 2024 again had just 15 new listings. By April 2025 the ratio was up to 108%. Over the past two winters, San Mateo's holiday months ran three to nine points below the spring that followed.
On a home listed at $2,000,000, 105% of list is $2,100,000 and 113% is $2,260,000. That $160,000 gap is the clearest measure of what a holiday buyer stood to gain over a spring buyer in the last cycle.
The county as a whole followed the same pattern, a little softer. San Mateo County single-family homes sold for 104% of list in December 2025, after an average of 33 days on market. In both months the city of San Mateo ran a point or so hotter than the county, and its homes sold faster.
The Median Price Overstates the Discount
A buyer who looks only at the median could conclude that San Mateo homes cost about 19% less in winter. The median was $1,920,000 in December 2025 and $2,375,000 in April 2026. Much of that gap comes from which homes were selling, not from lower prices for the same home.
The average San Mateo home that sold in December 2025 was 1,756 square feet. In April 2026 it was 1,944 square feet. December 2024 skewed smaller still, at 1,621 square feet. Smaller homes have lower prices, so a month weighted toward smaller homes pulls the median down even if no individual home got cheaper.
Median price per square foot gives a cleaner comparison. San Mateo's was $1,214 in December 2025 and $1,302 in April 2026, a gap of about 7%. March 2026 was the outlier at $1,496. A 7% gap still matters on a home in the $2 million range, but it is far smaller than the median suggests.
For a buyer, the holiday advantage comes in two parts. One is a smaller overbid, and the sale-to-list ratio shows it directly. The other is a modest discount per square foot. What a buyer gives up is choice: fewer homes, and a mix that leans toward smaller ones. A family that needs a four-bedroom house may find nothing that fits in a given December week. A buyer whose list includes a two-bedroom bungalow or a smaller three-bedroom will see more of their kind of home in the winter mix.
What Last Winter's Prices Look Like From Here
Prices since then show what the winter discount was worth. Median price per square foot for San Mateo single-family homes went from $1,214 in December 2025 to $1,356 in October 2026, an increase of about 12%. Comparing October to October, the figure rose from $1,238 in October 2025 to $1,356 in October 2026, about 9.5%.
Those gains came with fewer homes trading hands. San Mateo had 60 new single-family listings and 56 closed sales in October 2025. In October 2026 it had 43 new listings and 42 sales. Bidding this fall has also been uneven from month to month. Sale-to-list was 113% in August 2026, 107% in September and 108% in October.
Borrowing costs have moved against buyers over the same year. Freddie Mac's Primary Mortgage Market Survey put the average 30-year fixed rate at 7.11% for the week of November 12, 2026. The year-earlier reading was 6.24%, on November 13, 2025. Price per square foot rose in San Mateo anyway. Higher rates reduced the number of buyers who could compete, but not enough to bring prices down. Our mortgage calculator shows what a given rate means for a monthly payment. Rates change weekly, and this post is general information, not financial advice, so confirm your own numbers with your lender.
January Is When the Window Starts to Close
The holiday lull in San Mateo is short. New single-family listings went from 15 in December 2025 to 38 in January 2026, and sale-to-list rose from 105% to 108%. The year before was sharper. January 2025 had 40 new listings and sold at 111% of list, the highest ratio of that winter.
That 111% figure came from only 14 closed sales, so a few strong deals could have pushed it up. In both years, though, January brought back the sellers and the bidding together, weeks before the spring market started.
January's days on market are less helpful. The average was 30 days in January 2026, but that average includes homes that had been listed since the fall and carried into the new year. A home listed fresh in mid-January can attract a lot of interest even while the citywide average still looks slow.
For a buyer touring San Mateo this Thanksgiving week, the record shows a few things. The next five or six weeks have historically produced the fewest new listings and the smallest overbids of the year. The homes that come up will lean smaller. Price per square foot is the fairer way to compare them with what sold in spring. Once January begins, more homes come up, and so do the bids. Our San Mateo single-family buyer's guide has more on the city's housing types. If you are also weighing condos, our earlier post on reading San Mateo condo days-on-market figures looks at that market.
Questions Buyers Ask About the Holiday Market
Are sellers who list in December more willing to negotiate? The citywide numbers point to less competition, not to motivated sellers. Homes in San Mateo still sold above list in every month in the table, including December 2025 at 105%. In the holiday months a buyer is less likely to be up against several other bidders, but sellers still got more than their asking price.
Is the whole county quieter in December, or only San Mateo? The whole county. San Mateo County single-family inventory fell to 188 homes in December 2025, with 0.6 months of supply and a 104% sale-to-list ratio. If you are also looking in San Carlos or Belmont, expect the same seasonal slowdown there.
Should a seller wait until spring? Last spring, San Mateo sellers got higher sale-to-list ratios. They also had more listings to compete with, from 55 to 67 new listings a month between March and May 2026 compared with 15 in December 2025. A December listing faces less competition from other sellers and fewer buyers. Which works better depends on the home, and our home valuation tool is a starting point.
If you are deciding whether to keep touring through the holidays or wait for January's new listings, The Canlas Brothers can pull the price per square foot and sale-to-list history for the San Mateo homes on your list, so you know what to expect before you write a bid. Schedule your free Home Strategy Consultation.